On Sale At bananabaker.com!

1887 Old Judge Baseball Cards


Pete Gillespie 1887-90 Old Judge N172 - SGC 40

$108.39


1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Collins (New York, Sliding Head First) SGC Antique Card

$179.99


N172 1887 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL HALL OF FAME JIM O'ROURKE GREAT IMAGE SGC GRADED 40

$55.55


N172 1887 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL HALL OF FAMER ROGER CONNOR VERY STRONG IMAGE PSA

$55.55


1887 Old Judge baseball card Collins New York

$26.00


1887 Old Judge baseball card Johnston Boston no creases

$56.00


1887 Old Judge baseball card Tiernan New York no creases

$138.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Hank O'Day Pitching Hands At Chest PSA (Authentic)

$89.00


1887 Old Judge baseball card Emmett Seery Indianapolis no creases

$113.50


1887 Old Judge Cigarettes Nat Hudson N172 SGC 20 Fair 1.5 Card is 132 years old!

$139.99


1887 N172 Old Judge GERMANY LONG, CHICAGO MAROONS SGC CRYSTAL CLEAR NO CRACKS

$245.00


1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Swartzel Kansas Citys 450-3 GREAT IMAGE!

$499.99


1887-90 Old Judge N172 #178 Silver Flint BVG 4.5 Z26966 - NM-MT

$500.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Tim Keefe and Richardson 251-8 New Yorks

$2,179.99


1887 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Johnston Boston 248-1 GREAT IMAGE!

$279.99


1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Myers Washington 338-4 GREAT IMAGE!

$389.99


1887 Old Judge N172 GIL HATFIELD SGC A New York Giants Vintage Old Baseball Card

$154.95


1887 N172 Old Judge Jack McGeachy PSA 4 VG / EX

$360.00


1887 N172 Old Judge THOMAS OYSTER BURNS PSA 4 VG-EX Low Pop / Total Pop = 1

$999.99


1887 N172 Old Judge - Gillespie - New York - SGC 10

$170.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE ELTON CHAMBERLAIN BAT AT READY OVER R/SHOULDER PSA 1.5 (84

$195.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Arthur Cut Rate Irwin SGC 3 - VG

$530.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Cannonball Titcomb Pitch Hands At Chin VG 3

$500.00


1887 Old Judge N172 Ed Silch SGC 20 1.5 Denver

$185.00


1887 N172 Old Judge William Fuller SGC 1 St Louis

$220.00


1887 N172 Old Judge - Bill Farmer - 152-2 - Pittsburgh - SGC 20

$249.99


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE #255-1C ED HERR, MILWAUKEES, SGC20

$239.95


1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes King Kelly SGC Authentic

$875.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE #508-2B GEORGE WOOD, PHILADELPHIA, SGC 30

$279.95


1887 N172 Old Judge John Clarkson SGC 2.5 - GD+

$1,230.00


1887 Old Judge Mike Kelly Boston Portrait N172 PSA 3 VG $10,000 Kelly

$10,000.00


C.F. GENIUS (FRANK GENINS) 1887-1890 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Baseball Cards

$450.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE #54-3B ROBERT BURKS, SIOUX CITY, SGC20

$279.95


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HARRY STALEY PITTSBURGH R/HAND NECK HIGH PSA 4 MK (5917)

$525.00


1887 N172 Old Judge JOHN CLARKSON HoF PSA 3 VG

$860.00